The Controversy Over Carlo Acutis Relics Explained

* This website participates in the Amazon Affiliate Program and earns from qualifying purchases.

As the world anticipates the canonization of Blessed Carlo Acutis, the first millennial saint, a troubling controversy has emerged surrounding the illegal online sale of his alleged relics. This raises profound questions about religious relics, their significance, and the ethics of selling items purportedly tied to saints.

Recent reports indicate that Italian prosecutors are currently investigating claims regarding the unauthorized sale of Carlo Acutis relics on various online platforms. This investigation comes on the heels of a formal complaint lodged by Bishop Domenico Sorrentino of Assisi, where Acutis’ tomb is situated for public veneration. The bishop discovered that an alleged first-class relic, said to be a strand of Acutis’ hair, was auctioned online for an astonishing €2,000, leading him to take action against what he considers a scandalous act.

The bishop’s statement highlights a troubling trend: “On the internet, there is a marketplace for relics concerning various saints, such as our St. Francis, complete with a price list. Something impossible to accept.” This sentiment encapsulates the broader concern within the Catholic community regarding the commercialization of sacred items.

According to canon law, the sale of sacred relics is strictly prohibited. First-class and second-class relics can only be transferred through gifting and must be treated with respect. Significant relics, such as pivotal body parts, require special permission from the Vatican before they can be given away. The current situation raises the specter of fraud, as Bishop Sorrentino remarked, “We do not know whether the relics are real or fake.” This uncertainty not only poses a risk to potential buyers but also undermines the sanctity attached to such holy items.

The commercial sale of relics could potentially lead to a broader crisis of faith. If it were discovered that these relics are fabricated, it would signify not only a financial scam but also an affront to the religious beliefs of many. The online marketplace for relics exemplifies a digital age conundrum where something intrinsically sacred can be commodified, raising questions about the ethical implications of such acts.

As we approach the upcoming canonization Mass scheduled for April 27 in St. Peter's Square, the focus should remain on Carlo Acutis’ remarkable legacy. Known for his deep faith and revolutionary use of technology, Acutis inspired many young believers and became a role model for a generation. The controversy surrounding relics should not overshadow his contributions to the faith but rather encourage a conversation about the respect and treatment of sacred belongings.

Thus, while the investigation unfolds, it is crucial for the Catholic community and the public to reflect on the meanings attached to relics and the potential pitfalls of their commercialization. Reaffirming the sanctity of such items may not only restore faith in the authenticity of religious practices but also ensure that the memory of individuals like Carlo Acutis is held in the highest regard, free from exploitation or deceit.

* This website participates in the Amazon Affiliate Program and earns from qualifying purchases.

* This website participates in the Amazon Affiliate Program and earns from qualifying purchases.